video_id,title,disposition,reason,source_comment_ids,source_comment_urls,pair_judgments_json,semantic_input
Jdy09y0A4t0,How Gaia Changed Astronomy Forever,omitted_five_video_scope,"Supported topical recommendation; omitted to keep five entries spanning beginner observing, astronomy history, satellites, planetary science and imaging methods. No lower quality is inferred.",17036313,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17036313,"[{""comment_id"": ""17036313"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""yes"", ""review_note"": ""Recommendation is contextual: the explicit recommendation sentence targets the channel rather than this video alone.""}]",final_judgments.csv
hFSPHfZQpIQ,The Secret History of Silicon Valley,omitted_topic_fit_no,"Saved judgments classify the video as outside an astronomy-focused list, even if positively mentioned.",1003308,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1003308,"[{""comment_id"": ""1003308"", ""stance"": ""neutral_or_reference"", ""topic_fit"": ""no"", ""review_note"": ""Parent 1003256 supplies the naval-war scenario being rebutted.""}]",final_judgments.csv
dhbAEx2le7o,Top Beginner's Astronomy Books!,omitted_five_video_scope,"Supported topical recommendation; omitted to keep five entries spanning beginner observing, astronomy history, satellites, planetary science and imaging methods. No lower quality is inferred.",42387446;49536680,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42387446;https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49536680,"[{""comment_id"": ""42387446"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""yes"", ""review_note"": ""List-level endorsement applies to the named advice videos; not a content-quality verification.""}, {""comment_id"": ""49536680"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""yes"", ""review_note"": ""Shared list endorsement is quoted in the same source\u2019s 9IlmekWsEAQ row; omit the repeated extract to meet the combined report/card quotation budget.""}]",final_judgments.csv
mqLHz21wGA8,7 Common Mistakes Made by Beginning Amateur Astronomers,omitted_five_video_scope,"Supported topical recommendation; omitted to keep five entries spanning beginner observing, astronomy history, satellites, planetary science and imaging methods. No lower quality is inferred.",42387446,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42387446,"[{""comment_id"": ""42387446"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""yes"", ""review_note"": ""List-level endorsement applies to the named advice videos; not a content-quality verification.""}]",final_judgments.csv
NvslqVTNEWs,"Best Telescopes/Scope Combos at $200, $500, $1,000, $2,500, $5,000, $10,000 and $50,000 in 2022",omitted_five_video_scope,"Supported topical recommendation; omitted to keep five entries spanning beginner observing, astronomy history, satellites, planetary science and imaging methods. No lower quality is inferred.",42387446,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42387446,"[{""comment_id"": ""42387446"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""yes"", ""review_note"": ""List-level endorsement applies to the named advice videos; not a content-quality verification.""}]",final_judgments.csv
BQ-g2eWj0Fs,Top 3 Beginner's Telescopes!  Which one should you buy?,omitted_five_video_scope,"Supported topical recommendation; omitted to keep five entries spanning beginner observing, astronomy history, satellites, planetary science and imaging methods. No lower quality is inferred.",42387446,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42387446,"[{""comment_id"": ""42387446"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""yes"", ""review_note"": ""List-level endorsement applies to the named advice videos; not a content-quality verification.""}]",final_judgments.csv
p7bzE1E5PMY,Visualization of Quantum Physics (Quantum Mechanics),omitted_topic_fit_no,"Saved judgments classify the video as outside an astronomy-focused list, even if positively mentioned.",29524609,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29524609,"[{""comment_id"": ""29524609"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""no"", ""review_note"": "" Endorsement inferred from the recommendation-request context, not a per-video praise sentence.""}]",final_judgments.csv
xuCn8ux2gbs,"history of the entire world, i guess",omitted_topic_fit_no,"Saved judgments classify the video as outside an astronomy-focused list, even if positively mentioned.",29524609,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29524609,"[{""comment_id"": ""29524609"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""no"", ""review_note"": "" Endorsement inferred from the recommendation-request context, not a per-video praise sentence.""}]",final_judgments.csv
uD4izuDMUQA,TIMELAPSE OF THE FUTURE: A Journey to the End of Time (4K),deferred_topic_unclear,Astronomy focus remains uncertain in the saved pair judgments; stance labels are preserved separately.,29524609,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29524609,"[{""comment_id"": ""29524609"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""unclear"", ""review_note"": ""Potential cosmological relevance is provisional; no synopsis or transcript is supplied. Endorsement inferred from the recommendation-request context, not a per-video praise sentence.""}]",final_judgments.csv
l3whaviTqqg,Humanity was born way ahead of its time. The reason is grabby aliens.,omitted_five_video_scope,"Supported topical recommendation; omitted to keep five entries spanning beginner observing, astronomy history, satellites, planetary science and imaging methods. No lower quality is inferred.",29524609,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29524609,"[{""comment_id"": ""29524609"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""yes"", ""review_note"": ""Speculative subject; relevance is not validation of the predictions. Endorsement inferred from the recommendation-request context, not a per-video praise sentence.""}]",final_judgments.csv
LceY7nhi6j4,Will we grab the universe? Grabby aliens predictions.,omitted_five_video_scope,"Supported topical recommendation; omitted to keep five entries spanning beginner observing, astronomy history, satellites, planetary science and imaging methods. No lower quality is inferred.",29524609,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29524609,"[{""comment_id"": ""29524609"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""yes"", ""review_note"": ""Speculative subject; relevance is not validation of the predictions. Endorsement inferred from the recommendation-request context, not a per-video praise sentence.""}]",final_judgments.csv
7ImvlS8PLIo,"'A Universe From Nothing' by Lawrence Krauss, AAI 2009",omitted_five_video_scope,"Supported topical recommendation; omitted to keep five entries spanning beginner observing, astronomy history, satellites, planetary science and imaging methods. No lower quality is inferred.",29524609,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29524609,"[{""comment_id"": ""29524609"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""yes"", ""review_note"": ""Title-based subject inference is provisional. Endorsement inferred from the recommendation-request context, not a per-video praise sentence.""}]",final_judgments.csv
OSWszdSHkyE,NANOWAR OF STEEL - Uranus feat. Michael Starr (Steel Panther) | Napalm Records,omitted_topic_fit_no,"Saved judgments classify the video as outside an astronomy-focused list, even if positively mentioned.",25037275,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25037275,"[{""comment_id"": ""25037275"", ""stance"": ""neutral_or_reference"", ""topic_fit"": ""no"", ""review_note"": """"}]",final_judgments.csv
eYJwgEwxG-U,Let's Overreact!! Smart Scopes Take Over? Chinese Products are the Best? Astronomy is Dead!?,omitted_five_video_scope,"Supported topical recommendation; omitted to keep five entries spanning beginner observing, astronomy history, satellites, planetary science and imaging methods. No lower quality is inferred.",49536680,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49536680,"[{""comment_id"": ""49536680"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""yes"", ""review_note"": """"}]",final_judgments.csv
WgyRdnjRI4o,Emacs Org-mode: Organizing a Scientist's Life and Work by Prof. Carsten Dominik,omitted_topic_fit_no,"Saved judgments classify the video as outside an astronomy-focused list, even if positively mentioned.",32605650,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32605650,"[{""comment_id"": ""32605650"", ""stance"": ""neutral_or_reference"", ""topic_fit"": ""no"", ""review_note"": ""Three-level parent chain is truncated; the immediate claim being challenged is available.""}]",final_judgments.csv
GutJf9umD9c,The Sneakers - Too Many Secrets,omitted_topic_fit_no,"Saved judgments classify the video as outside an astronomy-focused list, even if positively mentioned.",25299540,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25299540,"[{""comment_id"": ""25299540"", ""stance"": ""neutral_or_reference"", ""topic_fit"": ""no"", ""review_note"": """"}]",final_judgments.csv
Dr20f19czeE,Breakthrough discovery in astronomy: first ever image of a black hole,omitted_no_supported_recommendation,"Topical reference exists, but no supplied pair combines recommendation stance with positive topic fit.",19624250,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19624250,"[{""comment_id"": ""19624250"", ""stance"": ""neutral_or_reference"", ""topic_fit"": ""yes"", ""review_note"": """"}]",final_judgments.csv
-Pc3IuVNuO0,The Controversial Exam Carl Sagan Gave His Students,deferred_topic_unclear,Astronomy focus remains uncertain in the saved pair judgments; stance labels are preserved separately.,47056937,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47056937,"[{""comment_id"": ""47056937"", ""stance"": ""neutral_or_reference"", ""topic_fit"": ""unclear"", ""review_note"": ""Course association alone does not establish the video\u2019s subject focus.""}]",final_judgments.csv
QCIRkD71do4,,deferred_topic_unclear,Astronomy focus remains uncertain in the saved pair judgments; stance labels are preserved separately.,7996303,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7996303,"[{""comment_id"": ""7996303"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""unclear"", ""review_note"": ""oEmbed returned 403; title and author remain unavailable. Broader program praise does not establish outtake topic.""}]",final_judgments.csv
ReOQ300AcSU,Homer Simpson vs Pierre de Fermat - Numberphile,omitted_topic_fit_no,"Saved judgments classify the video as outside an astronomy-focused list, even if positively mentioned.",6552042,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6552042,"[{""comment_id"": ""6552042"", ""stance"": ""neutral_or_reference"", ""topic_fit"": ""no"", ""review_note"": ""A favorable channel introduction could imply a soft recommendation, but this video is only described as related.""}]",final_judgments.csv
tJOJ6B2XOyA,,deferred_metadata_unavailable,"Supported topical recommendation, but public metadata is unavailable; retained for later consideration, not declared unplayable.",5224944,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5224944,"[{""comment_id"": ""5224944"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""yes"", ""review_note"": ""oEmbed returned 404; title and author unavailable. Initial hoax concern is not resolved by independent validation here.""}]",final_judgments.csv
hSuSG19Pcoc,Cherenkov Radiation,deferred_topic_unclear,Astronomy focus remains uncertain in the saved pair judgments; stance labels are preserved separately.,49981589,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49981589,"[{""comment_id"": ""49981589"", ""stance"": ""neutral_or_reference"", ""topic_fit"": ""unclear"", ""review_note"": ""Distinguish a supporting physics demonstration from a video focused on space science; no content was viewed.""}]",final_judgments.csv
mj5zn_Jz3dE,Long VS Short Exposures in Astrophotography - Part 1: Broadband Test,omitted_five_video_scope,"Supported topical recommendation; omitted to keep five entries spanning beginner observing, astronomy history, satellites, planetary science and imaging methods. No lower quality is inferred.",47936513,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47936513,"[{""comment_id"": ""47936513"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""yes"", ""review_note"": ""Three-level parent chain is truncated; immediate parent 47936177 identifies the disputed claim.""}]",final_judgments.csv
n1RbyswFUqs,Perfecting Astrophotography Exposure Lengths - A deep dive into exposure times vs sub count,omitted_five_video_scope,"Supported topical recommendation; omitted to keep five entries spanning beginner observing, astronomy history, satellites, planetary science and imaging methods. No lower quality is inferred.",47936513,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47936513,"[{""comment_id"": ""47936513"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""yes"", ""review_note"": ""Three-level parent chain is truncated; immediate parent 47936177 identifies the disputed claim.""}]",final_judgments.csv
ZWSvHBG7X0w,Do *you* understand ISO?,omitted_topic_fit_no,"Saved judgments classify the video as outside an astronomy-focused list, even if positively mentioned.",47936513,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47936513,"[{""comment_id"": ""47936513"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""no"", ""review_note"": ""Adjacent technical material; excluded from topic fit under a focus-on-astronomy definition. Parent chain truncated.""}]",final_judgments.csv
4J9MRYJz9-4,The largest number and cDonalds Theorem - Look Around You,omitted_topic_fit_no,"Saved judgments classify the video as outside an astronomy-focused list, even if positively mentioned.",47579661,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47579661,"[{""comment_id"": ""47579661"", ""stance"": ""neutral_or_reference"", ""topic_fit"": ""no"", ""review_note"": """"}]",final_judgments.csv
60OVlfAUPJg,Conrad Wolfram: Teaching kids real math with computers,omitted_topic_fit_no,"Saved judgments classify the video as outside an astronomy-focused list, even if positively mentioned.",4679838,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4679838,"[{""comment_id"": ""4679838"", ""stance"": ""neutral_or_reference"", ""topic_fit"": ""no"", ""review_note"": ""Disagreement with terminology does not by itself establish criticism of the video.""}]",final_judgments.csv
lyyZzzgoLNE,How to use JWST as a direct detector of DARK MATTER,omitted_no_supported_recommendation,"Topical reference exists, but no supplied pair combines recommendation stance with positive topic fit.",46709048,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46709048,"[{""comment_id"": ""46709048"", ""stance"": ""neutral_or_reference"", ""topic_fit"": ""yes"", ""review_note"": ""The unviewed older video mentioned in prose is not this linked video. Citation of authority is not automatically recommendation.""}]",final_judgments.csv
F4OhXQTMOEc,Bill Nye Destroys Noah's Ark,omitted_topic_fit_no,"Saved judgments classify the video as outside an astronomy-focused list, even if positively mentioned.",46585093,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46585093,"[{""comment_id"": ""46585093"", ""stance"": ""neutral_or_reference"", ""topic_fit"": ""no"", ""review_note"": ""Selected comment reproduces older material attributed to DonHopkins and links comment 42226224; quotation here is attributed to the supplied selected record, not a separately fetched older source.""}]",final_judgments.csv
NdSD07U5uBs,"Alan Kay, 2015: Power of Simplicity",omitted_topic_fit_no,"Saved judgments classify the video as outside an astronomy-focused list, even if positively mentioned.",46315093,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46315093,"[{""comment_id"": ""46315093"", ""stance"": ""recommend"", ""topic_fit"": ""no"", ""review_note"": ""Limited praise is not an assessment of the whole talk. Parent chain truncated.""}]",final_judgments.csv
ubaX1Smg6pY,,omitted_topic_fit_no,"Saved judgments classify the video as outside an astronomy-focused list, even if positively mentioned.",46315093,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46315093,"[{""comment_id"": ""46315093"", ""stance"": ""neutral_or_reference"", ""topic_fit"": ""no"", ""review_note"": ""oEmbed returned 404; title/author metadata unavailable. Unwatched by commenter; parent chain truncated.""}]",final_judgments.csv
