comment_id,video_id,source_url,status,changed_fields,old_stance,new_stance,old_topic_fit,new_topic_fit,old_stance_reason,new_stance_reason,old_topic_reason,new_topic_reason,old_quote_word_count,new_quote_word_count,evidence_reference,revision_reason
31451807,d0cjG1UdqKo,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31451807,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Directly praises this linked biography.,Directly praises this linked biography.,Comment and title identify the history of astronomy through Fraunhofer.,Comment and title identify the history of astronomy through Fraunhofer.,4,4,Original HTML for source 31451807; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
26458700,TifUa8ENQes,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26458700,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Explicit recommendation of this particular documentary.,Explicit recommendation of this particular documentary.,Comment and title concern Starlink and its effects on astronomy.,Comment and title concern Starlink and its effects on astronomy.,6,6,Original HTML for source 26458700; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
17036313,Jdy09y0A4t0,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17036313,clarified,stance_reason,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Appreciatively introduces this Gaia video while recommending its channel and praising its technical treatment.,"Appreciatively introduces this Gaia video in an endorsement of its channel. The technical-treatment praise is channel-level, not an explicit assessment of this particular video.",Both identify Gaia and changes to astronomy.,Both identify Gaia and changes to astronomy.,4,4,Original HTML for source 17036313; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Narrow technical-treatment attribution to the channel, as stated in the source, rather than imply a video-specific assessment."
1003308,hFSPHfZQpIQ,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1003308,unchanged,,neutral_or_reference,neutral_or_reference,no,no,"Cites a video to support a military-intelligence anecdote, without evaluating the video.","Cites a video to support a military-intelligence anecdote, without evaluating the video.",The argument concerns surveillance history; the title concerns Silicon Valley history. Astronomy is incidental.,The argument concerns surveillance history; the title concerns Silicon Valley history. Astronomy is incidental.,7,7,Original HTML for source 1003308; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
42387446,9IlmekWsEAQ,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42387446,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Lists this specific video under a favorable introduction to Ed Ting astronomy and buying advice.,Lists this specific video under a favorable introduction to Ed Ting astronomy and buying advice.,"Introductory amateur astronomy, binoculars and telescopes.","Introductory amateur astronomy, binoculars and telescopes.",3,3,Original HTML for source 42387446; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
42387446,dhbAEx2le7o,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42387446,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Lists this specific video under a favorable introduction to Ed Ting astronomy and buying advice.,Lists this specific video under a favorable introduction to Ed Ting astronomy and buying advice.,Beginner astronomy books.,Beginner astronomy books.,3,3,Original HTML for source 42387446; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
42387446,mqLHz21wGA8,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42387446,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Lists this specific video under a favorable introduction to Ed Ting astronomy and buying advice.,Lists this specific video under a favorable introduction to Ed Ting astronomy and buying advice.,Mistakes by beginning amateur astronomers.,Mistakes by beginning amateur astronomers.,3,3,Original HTML for source 42387446; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
42387446,NvslqVTNEWs,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42387446,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Lists this specific video under a favorable introduction to Ed Ting astronomy and buying advice.,Lists this specific video under a favorable introduction to Ed Ting astronomy and buying advice.,Telescope equipment and buying advice for observing.,Telescope equipment and buying advice for observing.,3,3,Original HTML for source 42387446; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
42387446,BQ-g2eWj0Fs,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42387446,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Lists this specific video under a favorable introduction to Ed Ting astronomy and buying advice.,Lists this specific video under a favorable introduction to Ed Ting astronomy and buying advice.,Beginner telescope selection.,Beginner telescope selection.,3,3,Original HTML for source 42387446; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
29524609,p7bzE1E5PMY,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29524609,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,no,no,Offers this named video as part of a direct answer to a request for recommended videos (root story 29523638).,Offers this named video as part of a direct answer to a request for recommended videos (root story 29523638).,General quantum mechanics visualization; no astronomy focus is supplied.,General quantum mechanics visualization; no astronomy focus is supplied.,3,3,Original HTML for source 29524609; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
29524609,xuCn8ux2gbs,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29524609,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,no,no,Offers this named video as part of a direct answer to a request for recommended videos (root story 29523638).,Offers this named video as part of a direct answer to a request for recommended videos (root story 29523638).,World history rather than an astronomy-focused video.,World history rather than an astronomy-focused video.,3,3,Original HTML for source 29524609; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
29524609,uD4izuDMUQA,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29524609,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,unclear,unclear,Offers this named video as part of a direct answer to a request for recommended videos (root story 29523638).,Offers this named video as part of a direct answer to a request for recommended videos (root story 29523638).,The title suggests a far-future journey but the supplied wording does not establish its astronomy content.,The title suggests a far-future journey but the supplied wording does not establish its astronomy content.,4,4,Original HTML for source 29524609; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
29524609,l3whaviTqqg,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29524609,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Offers this named video as part of a direct answer to a request for recommended videos (root story 29523638).,Offers this named video as part of a direct answer to a request for recommended videos (root story 29523638).,Humanity and hypothetical extraterrestrial expansion are framed as a cosmic timing question.,Humanity and hypothetical extraterrestrial expansion are framed as a cosmic timing question.,2,2,Original HTML for source 29524609; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
29524609,LceY7nhi6j4,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29524609,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Offers this named video as part of a direct answer to a request for recommended videos (root story 29523638).,Offers this named video as part of a direct answer to a request for recommended videos (root story 29523638).,Comment discusses alien encounters and predictions; title explicitly concerns the universe.,Comment discusses alien encounters and predictions; title explicitly concerns the universe.,2,2,Original HTML for source 29524609; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
29524609,7ImvlS8PLIo,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29524609,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Offers this named video as part of a direct answer to a request for recommended videos (root story 29523638).,Offers this named video as part of a direct answer to a request for recommended videos (root story 29523638).,The named lecture concerns the origin of the universe.,The named lecture concerns the origin of the universe.,4,4,Original HTML for source 29524609; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
25037275,OSWszdSHkyE,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25037275,unchanged,,neutral_or_reference,neutral_or_reference,no,no,Uses the link as a naming joke in reply to parent 25034628; does not evaluate the music video.,Uses the link as a naming joke in reply to parent 25034628; does not evaluate the music video.,The title identifies a music performance; the parent and selected comment supply a wordplay context.,The title identifies a music performance; the parent and selected comment supply a wordplay context.,3,3,Original HTML for source 25037275; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
49536680,eYJwgEwxG-U,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49536680,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Explicitly calls this video good.,Explicitly calls this video good.,Discusses smart scopes and the state of amateur astronomy.,Discusses smart scopes and the state of amateur astronomy.,7,7,Original HTML for source 49536680; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
49536680,9IlmekWsEAQ,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49536680,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Explicitly groups this link among good beginner advice videos.,Explicitly groups this link among good beginner advice videos.,"Books, binoculars and telescopes for starting astronomy.","Books, binoculars and telescopes for starting astronomy.",6,6,Original HTML for source 49536680; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
49536680,dhbAEx2le7o,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49536680,clarified,evidence_quote;review_note,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Explicitly groups this book-advice link among good beginner videos.,Explicitly groups this book-advice link among good beginner videos.,Beginner astronomy book advice.,Beginner astronomy book advice.,4,0,Original HTML for source 49536680; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Remove one duplicated four-word extract. The historical provisional card repeats the same source phrase; conservative combined counting was 21 words. Source relationship, stance and reasoning remain intact."
32605650,WgyRdnjRI4o,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32605650,unchanged,,neutral_or_reference,neutral_or_reference,no,no,"Uses a scientist’s Org-mode talk as a counterexample to parent 32605226, not as an explicit video recommendation.","Uses a scientist’s Org-mode talk as a counterexample to parent 32605226, not as an explicit video recommendation.","The title and discussion concern Emacs and scientific work organization, not astronomy content.","The title and discussion concern Emacs and scientific work organization, not astronomy content.",4,4,Original HTML for source 32605650; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
25299540,GutJf9umD9c,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25299540,clarified,stance_reason;topic_reason,neutral_or_reference,neutral_or_reference,no,no,Cites a film reference to illustrate code breaking; praise elsewhere concerns the research article.,Uses the link as a code-breaking reference; praise elsewhere concerns the research article rather than the linked clip.,The title identifies a Sneakers scene and the surrounding text concerns cryptography.,"The supplied title refers to Sneakers and secrets, while the comment uses it in a cryptography discussion. No astronomy-focused subject is established.",2,2,Original HTML for source 25299540; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,Remove the unverified film/scene identification; the supplied title and cryptography context suffice for the bounded reasoning.
19624250,Dr20f19czeE,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19624250,unchanged,,neutral_or_reference,neutral_or_reference,yes,yes,Supplies a descriptive press-conference link without a clear evaluation of the video.,Supplies a descriptive press-conference link without a clear evaluation of the video.,The root story and title identify the first black-hole image announcement.,The root story and title identify the first black-hole image announcement.,6,6,Original HTML for source 19624250; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
47056937,-Pc3IuVNuO0,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47056937,unchanged,,neutral_or_reference,neutral_or_reference,unclear,unclear,Cites discussion of Sagan’s course to answer a reading-list question in parents 47056823 and 47056694.,Cites discussion of Sagan’s course to answer a reading-list question in parents 47056823 and 47056694.,"An astronomy course provides context, but the title and comment emphasize an exam and reading list rather than space-science content.","An astronomy course provides context, but the title and comment emphasize an exam and reading list rather than space-science content.",11,11,Original HTML for source 47056937; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
9071833,KfODJpfS0fo,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9071833,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Explicitly recommends the linked Pluto lecture.,Explicitly recommends the linked Pluto lecture.,Comment and title concern the encounter with Pluto.,Comment and title concern the encounter with Pluto.,7,7,Original HTML for source 9071833; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
7996303,QCIRkD71do4,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7996303,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,unclear,unclear,Appreciatively presents this particular outtake about simplifying science programming.,Appreciatively presents this particular outtake about simplifying science programming.,"The speaker presents physics/astronomy programs, but the outtake itself concerns media treatment of science.","The speaker presents physics/astronomy programs, but the outtake itself concerns media treatment of science.",5,5,Original HTML for source 7996303; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
6552042,ReOQ300AcSU,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6552042,unchanged,,neutral_or_reference,neutral_or_reference,no,no,Introduces a related video; the explicit praise targets the Numberphile channel rather than this clip.,Introduces a related video; the explicit praise targets the Numberphile channel rather than this clip.,Comment and title identify mathematics in animated television; astronomy refers to other channels.,Comment and title identify mathematics in animated television; astronomy refers to other channels.,9,9,Original HTML for source 6552042; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
5224944,tJOJ6B2XOyA,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5224944,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Explicitly praises the meteor footage despite describing initial doubts about authenticity.,Explicitly praises the meteor footage despite describing initial doubts about authenticity.,The selected comment describes meteor footage and discusses asteroid association.,The selected comment describes meteor footage and discusses asteroid association.,5,5,Original HTML for source 5224944; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
49981589,hSuSG19Pcoc,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49981589,unchanged,,neutral_or_reference,neutral_or_reference,unclear,unclear,Uses the link as an illustration of Cherenkov radiation within an IceCube explanation.,Uses the link as an illustration of Cherenkov radiation within an IceCube explanation.,"Radiation is relevant to neutrino detection, but neither the generic title nor the comment establishes that the clip concerns astronomy.","Radiation is relevant to neutrino detection, but neither the generic title nor the comment establishes that the clip concerns astronomy.",4,4,Original HTML for source 49981589; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
47936513,T_k9B01AeFM,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47936513,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Explicitly includes this link in a list of videos enjoyed; criticism targets the parent’s noise claim.,Explicitly includes this link in a list of videos enjoyed; criticism targets the parent’s noise claim.,Statistics for astronomical imaging.,Statistics for astronomical imaging.,3,3,Original HTML for source 47936513; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
47936513,mj5zn_Jz3dE,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47936513,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Explicitly includes this link in a list of videos enjoyed; criticism targets the parent’s noise claim.,Explicitly includes this link in a list of videos enjoyed; criticism targets the parent’s noise claim.,Long versus short astrophotography exposures.,Long versus short astrophotography exposures.,3,3,Original HTML for source 47936513; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
47936513,n1RbyswFUqs,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47936513,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,yes,yes,Explicitly includes this link in a list of videos enjoyed; criticism targets the parent’s noise claim.,Explicitly includes this link in a list of videos enjoyed; criticism targets the parent’s noise claim.,Exposure duration and subexposure count in astrophotography.,Exposure duration and subexposure count in astrophotography.,3,3,Original HTML for source 47936513; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
47936513,ZWSvHBG7X0w,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47936513,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,no,no,Explicitly praises the explanation of ISO in this particular video.,Explicitly praises the explanation of ISO in this particular video.,The linked explanation concerns general camera ISO; it is applied to an astronomy argument but no astronomy-specific video focus is supplied.,The linked explanation concerns general camera ISO; it is applied to an astronomy argument but no astronomy-specific video focus is supplied.,3,3,Original HTML for source 47936513; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
47579661,4J9MRYJz9-4,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47579661,clarified,topic_reason,neutral_or_reference,neutral_or_reference,no,no,"Links a clip as the reason for a favorite number, without a clear evaluation of the video.","Links a clip as the reason for a favorite number, without a clear evaluation of the video.",Title concerns a largest-number theorem/comedy reference; astronomy occurs only in an unrelated list of number associations.,The title concerns a largest number and a named theorem; the comment uses it to explain a favorite number. Astronomy appears in a separate general observation.,6,6,Original HTML for source 47579661; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,Remove the unverified comedy characterization; it is unnecessary to the title/context-based topic decision.
4679838,60OVlfAUPJg,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4679838,unchanged,,neutral_or_reference,neutral_or_reference,no,no,Cites a talk in an education argument; proposes replacing its terminology without clearly judging the video favorably or unfavorably.,Cites a talk in an education argument; proposes replacing its terminology without clearly judging the video favorably or unfavorably.,Math education and computing are the subject; astronomy appears only in a proposed school-subject list.,Math education and computing are the subject; astronomy appears only in a proposed school-subject list.,12,12,Original HTML for source 4679838; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
46709048,lyyZzzgoLNE,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46709048,unchanged,,neutral_or_reference,neutral_or_reference,yes,yes,"Cites Dr. Becky as a counterexample to the article’s claims; the negative verdict targets the article, not this video.","Cites Dr. Becky as a counterexample to the article’s claims; the negative verdict targets the article, not this video.",Title concerns JWST and dark matter; comment explicitly discusses cosmological evidence.,Title concerns JWST and dark matter; comment explicitly discusses cosmological evidence.,4,4,Original HTML for source 46709048; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
46585093,F4OhXQTMOEc,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46585093,unchanged,,neutral_or_reference,neutral_or_reference,no,no,Uses the linked video to support a criticism of an ark claim; no explicit evaluation of the linked video.,Uses the linked video to support a criticism of an ark claim; no explicit evaluation of the linked video.,"Title and immediately preceding discussion concern Noah’s Ark, not the archaeoastronomy discussed earlier.","Title and immediately preceding discussion concern Noah’s Ark, not the archaeoastronomy discussed earlier.",16,16,Original HTML for source 46585093; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
46315093,NdSD07U5uBs,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46315093,unchanged,,recommend,recommend,no,no,Appreciatively presents a particular illustration in this talk; endorsement is limited to that example.,Appreciatively presents a particular illustration in this talk; endorsement is limited to that example.,Astronomical modeling illustrates software simplicity; the talk is presented as a software/design discussion.,Astronomical modeling illustrates software simplicity; the talk is presented as a software/design discussion.,4,4,Original HTML for source 46315093; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
46315093,ubaX1Smg6pY,https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46315093,unchanged,,neutral_or_reference,neutral_or_reference,no,no,Mentions another apparently relevant talk while explicitly saying it has not been watched; does not extend praise of the first talk.,Mentions another apparently relevant talk while explicitly saying it has not been watched; does not extend praise of the first talk.,The supplied talk name and software-complexity discussion indicate a design topic.,The supplied talk name and software-complexity discussion indicate a design topic.,6,6,Original HTML for source 46315093; first-pass and final tables keyed by this pair.,"Original wording, supplied context and metadata support the bounded existing interpretation; uncertainty retained."
